Skip to content
TrustedLine

A Holiday Tour de Force: Exploring Underrated Christmas Films

Something that bothers concerning a lot of present-day holiday films is their excessive self-consciousness – the ostentatious decor, the formulaic soundtrack tunes, and the clichéd conversations about the essence of the holidays. Perhaps because the genre was not hardened into tradition, films from the 1940s often approach Christmas from far more creative and less obsessive perspectives.

It Happened on Fifth Avenue

One cherished find from delving into 1940s holiday films is It Happened on Fifth Avenue, a 1947 semi-romantic farce with a great premise: a jovial drifter spends the winter in a vacant posh mansion each year. That season, he invites strangers to reside with him, including a ex-soldier and a young woman who happens to be the offspring of the property's wealthy owner. Filmmaker Roy Del Ruth infuses the movie with a makeshift family coziness that most contemporary Christmas stories have to labor to achieve. It perfectly balances a class-conscious story on affordable living and a charming city romance.

Tokyo Godfathers

Satoshi Kon's 2003 feature Tokyo Godfathers is a fun, sad, and profound take on the holiday story. Loosely based on a classic Hollywood film, it follows a group of down-and-out people – an alcoholic, a transgender woman, and a young runaway – who find an left-behind infant on a snowy December night. Their journey to reunite the infant's mother sets off a series of hijinks involving crime lords, immigrants, and apparently serendipitous coincidences. The movie celebrates the wonder of chance frequently found in Christmas tales, offering it with a cinematic animation that steers clear of saccharine feeling.

Introducing John Doe

While Frank Capra's It's a Wonderful Life rightly earns plenty of attention, his earlier film Meet John Doe is a notable Christmas tale in its own right. Starring Gary Cooper as a handsome "forgotten man" and Barbara Stanwyck as a resourceful journalist, the story starts with a fabricated letter from a man promising to leap from a building on Christmas Eve in despair. The nation's embrace leads the journalist to hire a man to impersonate the invented "John Doe," who then becomes a country-wide figure for community. The film serves as both an heartwarming story and a sharp critique of ultra-rich media magnates trying to use grassroots sentiment for political ambitions.

Silent Partner

Whereas holiday horror pictures are now plentiful, the Christmas thriller remains a strangely niche subgenre. This makes the 1978 gem The Silent Partner a fresh discovery. Starring a delightfully vile Christopher Plummer as a criminal Santa Claus and Elliott Gould as a clever bank teller, the film sets two types of opportunistic individuals against each other in a well-crafted and surprising narrative. Mostly ignored upon its first debut, it is worthy of new attention for those who prefer their festive stories with a dark edge.

Christmas Almost

For those who prefer their Christmas gatherings dysfunctional, Almost Christmas is a blast. Featuring a stellar cast that has Danny Glover, Mo'Nique, and JB Smoove, the film delves into the strain of a household compelled to share five days under one house during the festive period. Secret dramas bubble to the surface, culminating in moments of extreme humor, including a dinner where a weapon is brandished. Of course, the film arrives at a heartwarming ending, providing all the enjoyment of a holiday disaster without any of the personal aftermath.

The Film Go

Doug Liman's 1999 film Go is a Christmas-themed tale that functions as a teen-oriented interpretation on crisscrossing narratives. Although some of its edginess may feel dated upon rewatch, the film still offers plenty things to savor. These range from a cool role from Sarah Polley to a memorable scene by Timothy Olyphant as a charming supplier who amusingly wears a Santa hat. It captures a specific brand of 1990s movie vibe set against a Christmas scene.

Miracle at Morgan's Creek

The satirist's 1940s film The Miracle of Morgan's Creek skips traditional holiday sentimentality in return for cheeky humor. The film follows Betty Hutton's Trudy Kockenlocker, who ends up pregnant after a hazy night but cannot recall the soldier involved. Much of the humor stems from her situation and the attempts of Eddie Bracken's lovestruck Norval Jones to marry her. While not explicitly a Christmas movie at the beginning, the narrative culminates on the Christmas, making clear that Sturges has refashioned a clever take of the Christmas story, filled with his signature sharp style.

Better Off Dead

This 1985 teen film with John Cusack, Better Off Dead, is a textbook artifact of its era. Cusack's

About the author

Thomas Brewer

A cybersecurity analyst with over a decade of experience in evaluating online platforms and advocating for user privacy.

TrustedLine

Type to search articles.